One size motivates no one: how to get the best from different personalities

Here's a mistake almost every new manager makes. We assume that what motivates us will motivate everyone else.
If you love a target and a leaderboard, you'll set targets and leaderboards. If you value a quiet word of thanks, you'll give quiet words of thanks. Then you wonder why half the team responds brilliantly and the other half seems flat.
Motivation isn't one size fits all. The best managers notice what drives each person and flex their approach. In short, motivation is about connection, not control.
Start with yourself
Before you try to work out your team, take two minutes to answer these honestly:
Think of a time you felt genuinely motivated at work. Was it because you wanted to do the task, or because you had to?
What drives you most: purpose, recognition, achievement or security?
How might your team members differ from you?
Your own answers are your default leadership style. Knowing them shows you where you'll need to flex.
Intrinsic vs extrinsic motivation
There are two broad sources of motivation:
Intrinsic motivation comes from within. It's driven by purpose, enjoyment, autonomy, mastery and pride. People work hard because the work itself matters to them.
Extrinsic motivation comes from outside. Pay, bonuses, praise, recognition and deadlines all count, as does avoiding a negative outcome.
Both matter, and most people are a blend. But extrinsic rewards tend to get short bursts of effort, while intrinsic motivation sustains people through the long, hard stretches.
Daniel Pink's well-known TED talk, The Puzzle of Motivation, sums it up as autonomy, mastery and purpose. If you can give people more of those, you rarely need to push.
Four personality styles
Personality shapes how people process information, handle pressure, communicate and like to be led. A simple way to think about it is four broad styles. Nobody fits one box perfectly, but most of us lean towards one or two.
The Driver Results-focused, decisive and fast-moving. Drivers want the headline, the target and the freedom to get on with it. How to motivate them: be direct and brief, give them clear goals and ownership, and don't micromanage. Recognise results.
The Communicator Enthusiastic, sociable and full of ideas. Communicators are energised by people and by being noticed. How to motivate them: give public recognition, involve them in discussions, and let them share ideas. Help them turn enthusiasm into follow-through with clear next steps.
The Analyst Detail-oriented, careful and logical. Analysts want to get things right and need to understand the why. How to motivate them: give them the data, explain your reasoning, allow time to think, and avoid springing last-minute changes on them.
The Supporter Loyal, steady and team-minded. Supporters value harmony, stability and feeling valued. How to motivate them: offer reassurance and consistency, explain change early and kindly, and thank them personally. Check in, because they won't always tell you when they're struggling.
Try this: which style do you find easiest to manage? Which do you find hardest? Usually, the hardest is the one most unlike you.
Generations and culture
You'll often hear broad generalisations about generations. Treat them as conversation starters, not rules, because individuals vary enormously. Still, some patterns are worth knowing:
Generation X often value independence, efficiency and trust. Focus on outcomes rather than process.
Millennials often look for purpose, development and regular feedback. Connect their tasks to bigger goals.
Generation Z often value clarity, transparency, modern tools and wellbeing. Communicate directly and take mental health seriously.
Culture plays a part too. Some cultures value hierarchy and formality while others prefer equality. Some favour direct communication while others prefer a more indirect, relationship-based style. Expectations around praise, feedback and conflict can differ widely. If your team is diverse, ask people how they like to be recognised rather than guessing.
Five questions that reveal what motivates someone
The quickest way to find out what drives a person is to ask. Try these in your next one-to-one:
What's given you the most energy this week?
And what's drained you?
Which part of the job would you do more of if you could?
Where do you want to be in 12 months?
How do you like to be recognised?
The last one surprises managers more than any other. Some people would love a shout-out in the team meeting. Others would find it mortifying and would much prefer a quick personal message.
Put it into practice
Pick one person in your team and spend ten minutes reflecting on;
their likely personality style,
what motivates them,
how they prefer to communicate,
one adjustment you could make to how you lead them,
what kind of recognition would mean most to them.
Then make that one adjustment this week. Small changes, made consistently, are what turn a group of individuals into a motivated team.
If you got this far then being a better and more confident leader obviously means a lot to you. Book a discovery call with Kate today to understand how she could help you further, throuh training, coaching, leadership skills and outsourced HR. Book time with Kate Coulson: 30 minutes meeting



Comments